The Black Hat Practice of Twitter Bot Armies

At the recent Social Media Strategies Summit in London, I heard from a company called Automica. The crux of their business is to build armies of fake Twitter profiles with the ultimate aim of building relationships with unsuspecting Twitter users and asking them to re-tweet a link to a piece of their client’s content or a promotion. Makes sense right? Well if you ask me this a shoddy practice that goes against the core values of online relationship building and one that will ultimately come undone.  Let’s take a deeper look…

How do they do this?

1 – They create a target list of genuine Twitter users

2 – Those targets are then followed by a bot (these bots have real photos and bio info, they even have personas. Automica pay people in the Philipines to create these profiles) 

3 – The bots will start to interact with the targets, perhaps re-tweeting something they say

4 – After a while and some interactions (any actual discussion between bot and user is carried out by a real person behind the bot) they will DM (assuming a mutual follow is in place) the user and ask them to RT a tweet or tweet a link that is pertinent to the client)

What does the client get from this?

I challenged the presenter on a number of things, one being what they feel the client gets from this, the uneasy answer from the speaker was ‘awareness’. I’d love to see some facts around how much awareness is actually raised by this practice. I really doubt there are actually any tangible results outside of the old chestnut of ‘awareness’.

Skating on regulatory thin ice

The speaker mentioned that Twitter outlaws the creation of fake Twitter accounts. Rule broken. He also mentioned the work they are doing breaks ASA (Advertising Standards Authority Rules). I asked him what would happen if the ASA investigated and exposed the work of one of their clients – his response was ‘give me one example of when that has happened’. Very defensive. Did you know that in California it is now against the law to create fake social network accounts? Factoid!

Who is using this service?

My gut feel is that this type of service is probably used by businesses that don’t tend to be in a great moral place when it comes to their promotion – casinos and bookies etc.

Am I missing the point or being too sensitive? 

Is this a viable solution for brands? Am I just wearing my transparency and engagement hat and thinking too much? Will the walls come falling down on this type of action? Please do tell me your thoughts in the comments below)

(image - http://www.leilasrobotarmy.com/)

Mike

Enjoying reading The Social Penguin Blog? Why not subscribe to our RSS, follow us on Twitter or join Dave on Facebook.

The Social Penguin Blog is Bound for London

It may be a little quiet around here for the next few days folks as Mike and Dave are heading to London to attend the Social Media Strategies Summit. Don’t worry, we will be live tweeting from the event (follow us on @social_penguin) and you can keep track of all the happenings by using #SMSS. Mike will also publish key takeaways from each day whenever possible!

Its not too late to sign up! See this link to the GSMI (Global Strategic Management Institute) and book now!

Don’t miss out on speakers from Facebooksalesforce.comYouTubeDellNingSeesmic and more!

The Social Penguin Blog is an official media partner of Social Media Strategies Summit London.

How Globally Connected are UK Based Facebook Users? (INFOGRAPHIC)

Western Union have recently been running a Facebook app called ‘Your World’. The purpose of this exercise was to map the global connections of  Facebook users and give them a score based on the global perspective. What country is the UK Facebook brood most connected to? Take a look at the infographic below and find out! (click twice to expand).

Interesting stuff huh? So who are you most connected to?

Enjoying reading The Social Penguin Blog? Why not subscribe to our RSS, follow us on Twitter or join Dave on Facebook.

Five Tips to Get You Started on Mobile SEO

The Apple iPhone, Samsung Galaxy, HTC Android camera phone models that keep coming out seem like they’re appearing out of science fiction, but it won’t be long before everyone is carrying around devices that connect them strongly to the web. When this happens, SEO is not going to be what it is today. Not only will desktop web users be migrating to more mobile means of accessing data, Google is already evaluating web content differently when looking through a mobile lens. In order to get a head start on mobile search engine optimization, take the following steps in fixing up your website and/or blog:

Turn off the Flash light

The late Steve Jobs was no fan of Flash and it shows in the fact that the iPhone will not accept Flash no matter what mobile browser is being used. That means the majority of your potential mobile traffic won’t be able to visit your site if you use the platform. In addition, Google mobile PageRank is very persnickety about sites with Flash. It’s an easy way to spruce up your site, but in the age of HTML5 and other mobile-friendly alternatives, it isn’t worth it.

Reduce your image sizes

Big image files take so much longer to load than smaller ones, even on 4G networks. If big images are vital to the look and function of your website, then use CSS to create a more mobile-friendly version. Otherwise big pictures are just a waste of space when it comes to mobile traffic which can’t enlarge them past a 4-inch screen anyway.

Keep the important content centered

Since mobile web browsers can’t display most websites entirely on such a small screen, most automatically center onto the middle unless otherwise instructed to do so. It’s important to keep your content centered. While imperative for keeping mobile traffic from confusingly searching for content across a page that may take a minute to fully scan on a mobile device, this is something that makes sense for traditional traffic as well. Centered content is most likely to be read, and most likely to be clicked.

Reduce homepage backlinks

Too many links on your homepage will result in a number of things when it comes to mobile users. For one, the overload will slow down loading on a mobile device at reduced speed. Secondly, the links can corrupt the code causing confusion when creating multiple site mirrors through CSS. But the worst thing about too many links on a homepage as far as mobile users are concerned is that on a touchscreen they’ll more likely to accidentally click on them, sending them away from your site too quickly.

Test drive your site on mobile browsers

It might be hard to round up enough phones from the people you know to get a reasonable sample of what mobile users are seeing on your site, but it’s important to test your site through every mainstream mobile browser. Whether it’s the iPhone’s Safari browser, mobile Firefox, or the Android browser, examine your site through all of them to make sure it looks good and is easily found.

These strategies are sure to get you started. But don’t look at mobile SEO as some faraway science you can hold off on the understand of. The migration from desktop to mobile web browsing is already occurring and is only set to grow. Act now to have the best handle on it that you can get.

Enjoying reading The Social Penguin Blog? Why not subscribe to our RSS, follow us on Twitter or join Dave on Facebook.


Social Media Strategies Summit London – One Week To Go!

On October 25th, the Social Media Strategies Summit will be hitting London (Hilton Tower Bridge), bringing with it a glittering line up of speakers and the opportunity for you to have you organisation’s social media strategy assessed.

The three day conference will see speakers from Facebook, salesforce.com, YouTube, Dell, Ning, Seesmic and more.

The Social Penguin Blog will be in attendance, live Tweeting and blogging the action. You can follow the official hashtag too – #SMSS.

Its not too late to sign up! See this link to the GSMI (Global Strategic Management Institute) and book now!

The Social Penguin Blog is an official media partner of Social Media Strategies Summit London.

Hey There’s a Bad Blog Going Around About You, Seen it Yet? Bad Twitter Times!

Alert (19/10 08:36) – Watch out for ‘Found a funny picture of you!’  Twitter spam DMs, they are doing the rounds again. DO NOT CLICK!

I know I’m not everyone’s cup of tea (who is, right?) but I can’t believe how many bad blog posts have been written about me over the weekend! I’m so scared to read to them as I can be a real sensitive chap and may well break down in to tears…

That sinking feeling…

So you’ve all had them over the weekend yeah? DMs on Twitter along the lines of  ’Hey theres a bad blog going around about you, seen it yet?’ accompanied by a nasty link? Have you clicked one and then immediately felt your stomach move north as you realise you have been duped? I’d like to think the average Twitter user isn’t stupid enough to do so. Clearly I am wrong as the spread of this spam attack has been quick and massive.

How do you react?

When I receive one of these DMs from a Twitter contact I at first feel pity for them. Especially if the account in question is a business – pissing off your customers with spam DMs ain’t a great impression! The immediate thought is to stop following the account in question, almost as some sort of safe-guard as becoming a victim. The really nice thing to do would be to let them know as not all user may have released their fate. As a brand/business I would suggest you send public tweets apologising and perhaps even write a blog post (you are blogging, right?) that you can direct people to for more information and at the same time educate them in what to click, and what not to click.

What can I do if I have been hacked?!?

  • Change your password asap!
  • Go to twitter.com – settings > applications and revoke access to anything that looks dodgy
  • Never, ever click a dubious link again!!!

Spam! Is it Ham? (image - http://www.spam.com)

What can Twitter do?

Back in July we wrote about yet another really bad weekend for Twitter that involved crazy amounts of spam followers rearing their ugly (well actually quite often pretty) heads. Twitter seemed to get a grip of that after a couple of days. Will this one be dealt with as quickly? The issue here is that users are facilitating the spread by clicking. I don’t have a solution for Twitter, but it’s about time they made serious moves to get a grip of these incidents. I wouldn’t be putting any marketing budget in to a spam ridden network…

Over to you…

Have you been receiving these nasty DMs? Are you a business that fell for it and got hacked up good style? How have your followers reacted? What can Twitter do? Do share!

Update 17/10 21:06 GMT - We just got another ‘Bad Blog’ DM! It ain’t going away folks…

Update 17/10 @ 16:43 GMT - There now appears to be public spam along the lines of:

hey @xyz, @abc. @efg we have been flamed on @bfg’s blog post, check it out – <insert nasty hacker link>

This is a clever approach as it mentions people you tweet with. Beware!

Mike

Enjoying reading The Social Penguin Blog? Why not subscribe to our RSS, follow us on Twitter or join Dave on Facebook.

The Benefits of Sharing More (yes, more!)

Yes, you are reading right, I said share MORE! Listen up people! And businesses too…

Recently my enjoyment of Twitter has dwindled. I’ve been thinking why this may be the case. I definitely don’t spend as much time on it as used to, could it be that I just not giving it the time it needs? Have the people I follow stopped firing out golden nuggets of info and insight? It would be unfair to blame others.

I am a robot…

Then I cracked it. I’m not as human on Twitter as I used to be. I’ve turned in to an info – sharing robot with an occasional Tweet built into my software that attempts to show I am actually trying to be a person. I used to send out lots of tweets about the things I was doing/eating/reading/visiting. I would seek conversations to get involved in, comment on people’s updates and just generally be sociable, while at the same time being a content filter. I’ve not completely stopped this but it has definitely dropped off. I have realised that I am missing the conversations that sharing a bit of life and personality can generate.

Don't be a Robot. (image - http://blog.frag-ment-ed.com)

Get the right blend!

Of course, there is a blend that leads to a happy Twitter life. Sharing relevant and interesting information is key. Offering a balanced opinion is also a nice Twitter trait. Of course, it can be too easy to get in to a habit of over-sharing – no-one needs to know you are tired or bored or hate your job, but working in parts of your life can help to give you a nicely rounded Twitter experience. Your Twitter actions are out there for the world to see. Think how you would like others to see you. But don’t be false!

This approach not only applies to individuals, but brands too.

Keyboard warriors

You know the type, always got a bee in their bonnet about something? Sniping at people, brands and other innocent Twitter users? Nobody enjoys watching these clowns in action. The crazy thing is, there are people out there who have their own businesses, state so in their Twitter bio but proceed to give over an awful impression. Give it a rest. I wouldn’t even think about hiring a business if their figurehead was a full-on Twitter tosser. Opinions are good and healthy, but don’t ram them down people’s throats. In the words of Otis, try a little tenderness.

Go forth and share…

That’s what I’m going to do. See you there.

What do you think? Is it good to show a bit of life? Do you prefer a brand to have a little heart and fizz? Do tell…

If you want to share with me, you can do so on Twitter:


How Far Does £40 ($63) Go on Facebook and StumbleUpon Advertising?

StumbleUpon may not be the biggest social network kicking around (just 13million users compared to Facebook’s 500million), but back in January Statcounter released some stats suggesting that StumbleUpon actually drives more traffic to external websites than Facebook, despite its relatively small user base.

Stats from www.statcounter.com (click to expand)

I was recently promoting a blog post by Gartoo on StumbleUpon about how men and women disagree on what makes a home a happy place and I thought I’d run a little experiment – to compare the results of Facebook Ads vs. StumbleUpon Ads.

I set up an identical advert on StumbleUpon and Facebook with similar targeting options promoting the blog post. I allocated £40 budget to each platform and watched the analytics and insights to compare the differences between the two social advertising channels.

StumbleUpon Sent Ten Times As Much Traffic Than Facebook for the Same Cost

Using fairly standard Facebook targeting options my average cost per click was £0.75. Stumbleupon on the other hand charged a cost per click of £0.07, which could have been even cheaper had I not paid an extra £0.03 per click for location targeting!

For a £40 budget Facebook sent 53 visits.

For a £40 budget StumbleUpon sent 645 visits.

StumbleUpon traffic was higher quality than Facebook

This has a lot to do with targeting options, but based on the metrics in Google Analytics the StumbleUpon traffic appears to be far more engaged with the content than Facebook visits.

Both sources had a very high bounce rate (to be expected for a blog post), but Facebook visits seemed to have an average time on site of 0 seconds, suggesting that they were not happy to be leaving Facebook.com to read a blog post.

StumbleUpon on the other hand, had an average time on site of 33 seconds, suggesting that the visitors were more engaged than those from Facebook.

Stumbleupon delivered traffic faster than Facebook

Even with identical targeting options, Facebook only delivered on average 4 visits a day (although getting 10,000 impressions a day on average). StumbleUpon on the other hand sent approximately 100 visits a day. This means that StumbleUpon took just 5 days, compared to Facebook which took approximately 13 days to use up the budget.

Conclusion

The sample size of this experiment is small and results are going to vary based on the topic of the post, how interesting it is, time of the day, and many other variables that have not been taken into consideration. However, I think it’s fair to assume that StumbleUpon is underrated as a traffic generation tool – maybe not for sending qualified leads, but for sending bloggers looking for cool content to write about it’s awesome, and inexpensive compared to other popular social advertising systems.

This guest blog post was written by Marcus Taylor, head of social media at SEOptimise and co-author of the book Get Noticed.

Enjoying reading The Social Penguin Blog? Why not subscribe to our RSS, follow us on Twitter or join Dave on Facebook.

The Check-in is Dead, Long Live the Check-in.

Ok, so this week I’ve seen a couple of articles about whether or not checking in to places on Foursquare, Facebook Places etc is dead.  I presume this is down to Facebook’s (supposed) announcement that they were withdrawing their location services, which many read as them conceding to Foursquare, and Gowalla’s pivot to focus on creating guides and hotspots.

Being based in the field (not literally a field, you can’t even check in there) of location based social networking, I figured The Social Penguin would be a good place to weigh in with my thoughts.

Checking In Should Be More Exciting Than This Type of Check-in!

I will confess now that I don’t really understand the point in checking in.  There, I said it.  The few times I’ve checked in, it’s been to seize a mayorship so I can get free burritos or because I’m somewhere cool; ‘Oh, Google’s UK headquarters? Yeah, I was just stopping by for a chat with some guys I know.’  Other than that, I fail to see the benefits of checking in – nobody needs to see me check in at the gym every other day, just like nobody needs to hear what I’m having for breakfast every day or what the weather’s like outside my window.  But try telling that to some of the people I follow on Twitter…

Do I think the future of social networking is the check-in?  Definitely not. I will admit that there are some apps making good use of check-in data.  Sonar, for example, notes your Foursquare check-ins and sends you an email if someone who follows the same people you do are in the area.  It’s easy to see the benefits of this at something like a conference, but the model is inherently flawed because of how many people use Twitter to follow celebrities, publications etc – just because someone who reads Vice and watches Glee is on the same street as me doesn’t mean we’re going to have anything else in common.

So what is the future of location?  Well, here comes the plug.  I work at Floxx Media Group, who are set to release an app called Spottd.  The most important realisation we had when building Spottd was that (with a few rare exceptions) places aren’t interesting; what’s happening there is what matters.  While my Twitter followers probably don’t care that I’m at Chilango’s, they probably would care if there was a cool new piece of street art round the corner, or the restaurant was giving away free burritos.  We hope to establish Spottd as a real-time social satnav – you can see things going on around certain locations, posted by people you may not know, and vote them up or down.

If you’re not a fan of product placement, you have my apologies (but if you are, you can follow our progress @SpottdDog on Twitter).  However, with or without the mention of the product I’ve been working on, everything I have written still represents how I feel about the future of location based social networking.

And now, this is the part of the (proverbial) evening where I throw things over to you guys – do you check in to places, and do you ‘get it’ or is just a habit you’ve managed to get into?  Would you be sceptical about a service like Spottd that is, in many ways, a real life version of Reddit or Digg?

Enjoying reading The Social Penguin Blog? Why not subscribe to our RSS, follow us on Twitter or join Dave on Facebook.

Why Twitter Follower Numbers Are Only Half the Story

Businesses, marketing professionals, and even individuals with personal Twitter accounts often obsess over getting more Twitter followers. They might believe that the number of followers a Twitter account has determines its ultimate value, but that’s only one part of the story. All those followers are of little value if you can’t influence them or meaningfully engage with them.

So yes, your reach is important, but ultimately engagement is the main metric you should track. How often your followers respond or reach out to you — and how often you do to them — determines the success of your social media marketing strategy.

Get a crowd, and harness it. (credit http://www.flickr.com/photos/sreejithk2000/2385193167/)

Fortunately, there are tools that help you do this, such as Sprout Social, a web application that lets you manage all of your social media accounts, publish updates to them, and receive reports on how you’re doing.

What Is Engagement?

When people talk about engagement in the context of social media, they’re usually talking about how much you interact directly with customers or other contacts through messages, and how much they interact directly with you.

For example, you’re doing a good job engaging on Facebook if you are receiving comments from people who’ve Liked your Page, and you’re responding promptly and helpfully to those comments.

Sprout Social Inteface

Building relationships with people, answering their questions, and challenging them with great content holds up your end of the engagement bargain. You’ll want to track how effectively and frequently you’re doing all of these things, but you’ll also want to track how and when people are responding to your updates and attempts at engagement.

If you can identify what works and what doesn’t, you can improve your methods and get better results.

Using Social Media Management Tools to Track Engagement

Since Twitter doesn’t give you any raw data to track that represents your engagement level, it can be difficult to track your progress and success. Fortunately, there are tools that do that — and much more — for you.

Ours is called Sprout Social, and it’s essentially a social media identity manager and publishing platform. You can use it to log in to your Twitter account or your Facebook page to publish updates, respond to followers, and generate reports that track your engagement and other important metrics and trends.

Though you can use it to publish updates and see updates from people you’re following on Twitter like many other web applications, Sprout Social has a dashboard that shows you two figures — your engagement and your influence. The first is everything we’ve been discussing, while the latter represents the number of people you can influence through the social media channels you’ve connected to the application.

Sprout Social Reports

The more detailed reports include more detailed data like what percentage of your posts are promotional and what percentage are conversational (you want a good balance), publication rates, and follower demographics. Facebook reports allow you to see which content is performing well in terms of comments and impressions, and Google Analytics is supported as well.

The Secret: Nothing’s Changed With Social Media

Many of the same principles that customer service representatives and salespeople learn when interacting with customers or clients on the phone or in person also apply to online media — most notably, that it’s all about building and maintaining relationships. Just converse with people on Twitter and Facebook and you’ll have the basics of engagement down.

As with all things, the technology has changed, but people have essentially stayed the same. Build those relationships and track those metrics just like you would any others in the offline world, and you’ll succeed in your attempts to build an audience. More engagement leads to more followers, not the other way around.

Samuel Axon is Editorial Director at Sprout Social, a company that provides social media tools for businesses. He’s the editor of social Web business guide Sprout Insights, and has worked as a writer and editor for Mashable, CNN, Forbes, USA Today, Yahoo!, and Engadget.

Sprout Social is the social media management partner for The Social Penguin Blog.

Enjoying reading The Social Penguin Blog? Why not subscribe to our RSS, follow us on Twitter or join Dave on Facebook.